Customising your timeline
As a user of Facebook or Instagram, you get to see a timeline composed by algorithms by default. Those algorithms determine which posts, photos and videos appear, based on your interests. You can switch to a timeline with friends' posts, but the apps don't remember that choice. Exactly that is now to change.
The preliminary relief judge in Amsterdam ruled that this practice violates the European Digital Services Act (DSA). According to the judge, this is a so-called dark pattern: a design choice that restricts users in their freedom of information. Within two weeks, Meta must adjust the apps in the Netherlands so that you can easily switch timelines and the apps remember your preferences. The judge stressed that this is also important in view of the 29 October elections.
Lawsuit
The lawsuit had been filed by Bits of Freedom, a Dutch foundation dedicated to digital civil rights. According to the organisation, the way Meta forces users to an algorithmic timeline is a risk to democracy.
Spokesperson Maartje Knaap stated, "It is unacceptable that tech billionaires determine how we see the world. That concentration of power poses a risk to democracy, especially in times of elections." Bits of Freedom is satisfied with the ruling, but called it a pity that going to court was necessary to force compliance with the law.
Incidentally, the battle does not seem to be completely over. Meta maintains that it already complies with European rules. The company argues that being able to switch timelines with "a few clicks" is enough. During the hearing, Meta also pointed to technical obstacles, which they say make quick adjustments almost impossible. Also, Meta believes that this is not a case for a Dutch court, but for the European Commission. They act as regulator.
Should the ruling stand, it means that you will have continued control over the timeline in Facebook and Instagram. For example, you can then indicate that you only want to see the timeline with updates from friends. This will then be preserved, without being reset to the version determined by the algorithm every time.
